There is a saying that exactly fits the reactions of the right and the left to Charlie Kirk’s memorial service: one screen, but two movies.
Over 100 million people tuned in to see at least some portion of the memorial service, and many millions more will watch clips from various speeches or the commentary around the event. A hundred thousand people, more or less, were inside the building, and tens of thousands were at the site of the event and couldn’t get a seat inside.
Erika Kirk (and supporters) had to memorialize Charlie from behind bulletproof glass.
Liberals have the luxury of cheering for Charlie’s death in the streets, safe and unafraid.
Never forget that contrast. pic.twitter.com/LtWli6bkA6
— Amiri King (@AmiriKing) September 21, 2025
Two planeloads of White House officials attended, including the President and Vice President, both of whom spoke. The vast majority of the content focused on Charlie’s faith in Jesus Christ or his mission to evangelize for his beliefs in freedom, persuasion, or his religion.
All true. Notice that politics are not on the list. That said, politics can be necessary to secure the freedoms to accomplish these things. https://t.co/KzhTJ53qWL
— Rod Dreher (@roddreher) September 21, 2025
His wife spoke of forgiveness.
If you watch one thing today, let it be this — the truly remarkable display of grace and compassion from Mrs. Erika Kirk as she forgives her husband’s assassin because that’s what Christ would do.
We love you, Erika. pic.twitter.com/EsSUgeJx1F
— Rapid Response 47 (@RapidResponse47) September 21, 2025
It was, by any measure, a powerful tribute to the man and his cause.
What did the left see? A fascist rally filled with hate.
This Charlie Kirk “memorial” is indistinguishable from a Nazi rally and fuck anyone who wants to pretend it’s not.
— Destiny | Steven Bonnell II (@TheOmniLiberal) September 21, 2025
Pastor here. Fyi, Fourth Reich political rallies are NOT memorial services.
— Dr. Kevin M. Young (@kevinmyoung) September 22, 2025
A significant number of the largest left-wing influencers’ accounts found the Charlie Kirk memorial not only repulsive–I can understand that completely–but actually hateful and dangerous to the country.
These kinds of lies got Charlie Kirk killed.
They know it.
They don’t plan on stopping. https://t.co/qE9OEVAWMo
— RBe (@RBPundit) September 22, 2025
One screen, two movies.
There is not one person who honestly believes that if Charlie were a liberal and assassinated, entire city centers would be boarded up in anticipation of riots. We know that because it has happened countless times in recent years. Instead, conservatives held candlelight vigils, prayer meetings, and peacefully organized.
Virginia Tech professor Nick Copeland calls a @TPUSA vigil for Charlie Kirk “the ideological equivalent of a Klan rally.” The vigil replaced what was supposed to be Kirk’s scheduled campus visit next week.
While Copeland wants the free speech to denounce others, he has some… pic.twitter.com/sOmT7a7r6J
— Stu Smith (@thestustustudio) September 16, 2025
We are not the same.
The cold-blooded murder of Charlie Kirk and its aftermath have spotlighted the pure evil that’s SO shockingly rampant in our country today. This absolutely must serve as the #TurningPoint for America. #WeAreCharlieKirk pic.twitter.com/4Swi0RPOqW
— 🇺🇲 ListlessTreeperMG 🇺🇲 (@ListlessMg) September 22, 2025
The thing is that liberals truly believe that they are the good ones, and talking about Jesus and saving our culture from forces that loudly proclaim that destroying it is their goal is fascist and dangerous. They see all that talk about Jesus and the importance of Western Civilizations as truly dangerous.
A society that equates argument with injury will normalize violence toward opinion. What’s worse, the ideology that seeded this holds radical views far outside the values of middle America. 3 pic.twitter.com/G0hGxk8Ch6
— Peter Boghossian (@peterboghossian) September 19, 2025
They equate words with harm, and far from reaching deep into their souls and finding the capacity to reach out in the face of actual violence, they go directly to armed conflict. They have declared war on God and are infuriated every time we reaffirm our faith. In a way, they are right that faith and commitment to Western ideals is an existential threat to them, because their own religion demands our destruction.
The guy who shot up the ABC affiliate in Sacramento worked for the CA teachers union. This is how he reacted to Charlie Kirk’s assassination. pic.twitter.com/bK00xWJZ4N
— Tom Bevan (@TomBevanRCP) September 20, 2025
Doctors, lawyers, teachers, judges, and even elected officials celebrated Charlie’s death, and as they see us mourn him they see Nazis rallying.
Graham Linehan was arrested for saying that if a man refused to leave a women only space he should be punched in the balls.
This woman exhorts her followers to kill those she disagrees with politically and suffers no consequences at all.
Make it make sense. https://t.co/zCi5KDsjEX
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) September 20, 2025
Liberals are even declaring that Charlie’s assassination was the MAGA Reichstag fire–the Reichstag was set on fire by the Nazis themselves to generate rage and violence through creating a hoax. They are literally saying that MAGA killed Kirk as an excuse to terrorize liberals.
🤔
Former Assistant Secretary of HUD Catherine Fitts:
“The Kirk assassination is a psyop, &… it’s a complete waste of our time… you’re watching a concerted effort to shred the Constitution, & I hate to say it, but the Charlie Kirk assassination was the Reichstag fire.” pic.twitter.com/0lRCHoWbP5
— Raymond (@Raymond82310289) September 22, 2025
This is so goddamn depressing. I’ve been saying for years that our problems with epistemic hygiene have been getting worse on the left, and here, arguably *the* most successful left-of-center public intellectual makes my point for me https://t.co/7lSth9WDXy
— Jesse Singal (@jessesingal) September 15, 2025
How do we come together when we live in two different realities? Honestly, I don’t know.
But what I do know is that Charlie’s assassination has sparked a revival of faith in God and faith in Western values, including the importance of trying to do so. And not only on the right, but for many in the center and the center left. The left will hate us no matter what, but we can marginalize them.
Watching the Charlie Kirk rally on CNN pic.twitter.com/hyjWoHHOra
— Julián🇲🇽🐌 (@rexdelay) September 21, 2025
We expect too much if the goal is to persuade everyone. It never works that way. The worst parts of our souls are never eradicated, only subdued. Western Culture, as with every human society, has always had its enemies. What makes a culture is the Overton Window–the center around which most opinion coalesces and the extent to which respectable opinion stretches. Charlie, both in life and in death, moved the Overton Window.
“Nuremberg rally” Really? There were prayers and Erica Kirk got the longest standing ovation of the night when she publicly forgave the killer.
I wonder how this reactionary clown professor of European politics reacted to the riots and looting after the killing of George Floyd? https://t.co/1UQQpGeW3t
— Stella O’Malley (@stellaomalley3) September 22, 2025
It is too much to expect that people who have declared us an existential threat will grant even a bit of grace to us, and we have to be OK with that. They are right that we are enemies who are fighting for the soul of America, although very wrong about us being Nazis.
We don’t use Brownshirts to break windows, steal things, and beat people up.
Two and a half minutes straight of Democrats calling for violence.
The Democratic Party is the party of violence. pic.twitter.com/mCTd0CbCnJ
— Libs of TikTok (@libsoftiktok) June 15, 2025
But just as Christians recognize that the battle between good and evil is never fully won, we have to be satisfied with every temporary victory.
The two movies/one screen phenomenon is a result of the human condition. We can convince individuals one by one to see our movie and not the left’s, but at some level, we must accept that, at best, there will remain a rump group who refuse to see even the most obvious reality.
Such is life. We just have to make certain that the majority remain grounded in reality.
Join Hot Air VIP and use the promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your VIP membership!