It is the best-selling memoir turned major film adaptation mired in controversy after doubts were raised about the veracity of its storyline.
Key elements of The Salt Path – billed as author Raynor Winn’s ‘unflinchingly honest’ account of homelessness – have been called into question after the 2018 book was turned into a movie starring Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs.
Winn’s claims of losing her 17th century farm cottage when an investment in a childhood friend’s business goes awry is false according to an investigation by a Sunday newspaper published last weekend.
The Observer instead claims that Winn and her husband Moth lost their property in North Wales when it was repossessed after having stolen £64,000 from former employer, Martin Hemmings who ran an estate agents in the town of Pwllheli.
The couple failed to repay a loan taken out with a relative to repay the stolen money – agreed on terms that the police would not be further involved – and so lost their house, the paper claimed.
It is a view backed up by Mr Hemming’s sister, Jill, who today spoke for the first time of her frustration that Winn ‘spun many lines’ to make a fortune from her book and the rights to the film of the same name.
As The Observer stated, Miss Hemmings said her brother, who died in 2012, knew The Salt Path’s protagonists, Raynor and Moth Winn by their less flamboyant legal names, Sally and Tim Walker.
Speaking from her home in Dorset, Miss Hemmings told MailOnline: ‘The book was triggered by Sally deceiving my brother, taking the money, stealing it away from him.
Raynor Winn at home in Cornwall. She has become a huge success since her book’s release, including two more books
Pictured: Jill Hemmings who today spoke for the first time of her frustration that Winn ‘spun many lines’ to make a fortune from her book and the rights to the film of the same name
Following an investigation into their backgrounds, The Observer said that The Salt Path’s protagonists, Raynor Winn (right) and her husband, Moth Winn (left), could have misled fans
‘And he was mortified. He was heartbroken by what happened.
‘I’m glad it’s out in the open at last. I hadn’t known the whole story so some of it I’m learning about now and it’s a sad that Sally needed to do that.
‘But she and her husband brought it on themselves. I don’t know all the ins and outs but I know that Sally worked for my brother, she was his secretary, and she took money from my brother and he was heartbroken.
‘He said he couldn’t understand why there never seemed to be any money in the account and then he found out it was her.
‘He was such a lovely person he didn’t want to prosecute. He just wanted everything to settle down really, which is why the matter never went to court.’
Asked if she had read the book or intended to watch the film, Ms Hemmings said: ‘ I have two copies of the book and I had a ticket to go to the film yesterday but I didn’t go – I boycotted it.
‘What I’m interested in is whether the publishers of the book and the film-makers looked into the situation? If they’d really looked into the situation I’m sure they would’ve found the truth really of what had been going on.
‘If you talk to the people of Pwllheli, they support Martin absolutely. He was a very good and well respected man and was always honourable.
The Winns with Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs, the stars of the recent film adaptation. It has been claimed that the couple may have made millions from the book and movie
Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs in the film adaptation of The Salt Path, which was released in May this year
‘All this happened a good few years ago but I must say that I got very upset this week because it brought back my brother’s death which was a tremendous sadness.
‘This weighed heavily on him before he died. He was very upset that someone who’d he been very generous to, very helpful to, had abused him like that. He couldn’t believe it.’
The memoir detailed the journey Winn and her husband took along England’s South West Coast Path – familiarly known as The Salt Path – after they lost their home in 2008 which coincided with Moth receiving a terminal health diagnosis of Corticobasal Degeneration (CBD), a rare brain progressive brain disease.
Neurologists and researchers have expressed scepticism that someone could have survived for so many years with CBD, which has a life expectancy of around six to eight years.
And Miss Hemmings said: ‘I think it’s important that people have a clearer idea of what the truth is – i don’t know what the whole truth is – but I’m suspicious that Moth could walk that coastal path. It’s crazy stuff.
‘I’m intrigued with the debate about his illness and what’s she made of that but it did seem to be quite outrageous that if he was that ill she’d set off walking with him like that. It seemed to be beyond the pale, I couldn’t understand why she’d do that because it didn’t seem like a particularly loving action.
‘I feel sorry for my sister-in-law in North Wales because she’s got a difficult path now, she’s probably pleased that some of the truth is out but lawyers will be probably delving into it. She’s on her own but she’s a very stoic and special lady.
The Winns at a gala screening of The Salt Path film in Newquay, Cornwall earlier this year
‘My brother lived very simply, had a small holding and the fact that Sally was not banking the money that was there was bloody sh** not to put a too finer point on it !
‘They’ve made a lot of money selling their book and now the film. I’ve no idea why she said what she said. I would say Raynor spun a lot lines.
‘Still, they have to live with themselves. I wonder if they sleep at night.
Winn this week issued a stern rebuke to the claims made in The Observer, chief among them the allegation she stole or embezzled money from Mr Hemming’s company.
She wrote: ‘I worked for Martin Hemmings in the years before the economic crash of 2008. For me it was a pressured time. It was also a time when mistakes were being made in the business. Any mistakes I made during the years in that office, I deeply regret, and I am truly sorry.
‘Mr Hemmings made an allegation against me to the police, accusing me of taking money from the company. I was questioned, I was not charged, nor did I face criminal sanctions.
‘I reached a settlement with Martin Hemmings because I did not have the evidence required to support what happened.
‘The terms of the settlement were willingly agreed by both parties; Mr Hemmings was as keen to reach a private resolution as I was. A part of that settlement was that I would pay money to Mr Hemmings on a ‘non-admissions basis’.
‘Among the Observer’s many accusations, the most heart breaking is the suggestion that Moth has made up his illness. This utterly vile, unfair, and false suggestion has emotionally devasted Moth, who has fought so hard against the insidious condition of Corticobasal Syndrome.
‘The effect of the suggestion that Moth has made up this condition has been absolutely traumatising for him. Suggestions made by people, who do not know him, have never met him, and have never seen his medical records.’
