A Labour-led council has ordered an owner to repaint over their Palestinian flag beach hut on an ‘iconic’ seafront, claiming that it fails to adhere to ‘standards’.
Brighton and Hove City Council have declared that Alison Lesley, who has had her beloved beach hut for six years, is in breach of her beach hut licence as strictly vertical stripes or a solid colour are permitted.
The retired psychotherapist, who described the decision as ‘pathetic’, was initially told she had just three days to remove the design, though this was later extended to a week.
Were she not to remove the flag, which the council say has received numerous complaints, the public body insisted they would do it themselves and then charge her for the work.
In an email addressed to Ms Lesley, a member of the council said that the body have a ‘very strict policy on the presentation of beach huts’.
Defending their decision, they added that the Palestinian flag ‘is likely to interfere with community cohesion’, with the likelihood of causing ‘distress and upset’.
Speaking to The Argus, Ms Lesley described the decision as ‘one-sided’ and ‘unfair’, arguing that another beach hut along the popular stretch of seafront has been painted with a French flag for the last two years.
She said: ‘I told the council for every one person who has made a complaint I can find ten that would approve.’
Labour-led Brighton and Hove City Council have declared that Alison Lesley, who has had her beloved beach hut (pictured) for six years, has breached her beach hut license by painting it with a Palestinian flag
The retired psychotherapist, who described the decision as ‘pathetic’, was initially told she had just three days to remove the design, though this was later extended to a week. Were she not to remove the flag, the council said they would do it themselves and then charge her for the work
In an email addressed to Ms Lesley, a member of the council said that the body have a ‘very strict policy on the presentation of beach huts’. Defending their decision, they added that the Palestinian flag (pictured) ‘is likely to interfere with community cohesion’
The 77-year-old insisted that the beach hut was painted in a bid to show support for those in Palestine amid the ongoing Israel-Hamas conflict.
Local councillor Birgit Miller, cabinet member for culture, heritage and tourism, told the Argus that the public body had asked Ms Lesley to repaint the beach hut ‘as the current design doesn’t adhere to the licence agreement and painting standards’.
Adding that the beach huts along the seafront are an ‘iconic feature’ and should therefore be protected as such, Cllr Miller said: ‘It’s important licence holders comply with their agreements’.
Members of the Hove Beach Hut Association, a local forum for residents who own their own residence along the beachfront, shared mixed responses regarding the council’s decision.
While one declared they could ‘only hope’ that Ms Lesley had her licence removed as a result of the controversial painting, another insisted that the ‘fun police’ should ‘get a life’, arguing that the decision was unjustified.
In October 2023, Brighton and Hove Council announced controversial plans for a 10 per cent effective sales tax for beach hut owners in a bid to plug a £70million black hole in its budget.
The fee, based on the sale price from April 2023, was proposed by councillors in lieu of raising the annual £503.60 licence fee and ownership transfer fee of £82 if they sell up.
However, owners of the iconic huts insisted that the terms of the licences amounted to ‘extortion’ and accused the council of ‘bullying’ and ‘coercive behaviour’.
Local councillor Birgit Miller, cabinet member for culture, heritage and tourism, told the Argus that the public body had asked Ms Lesley to repaint the beach hut ‘as the current design doesn’t adhere to the licence agreement and painting standards’
Speaking to The Argus, Ms Lesley described the decision as ‘one-sided’ and ‘unfair’, arguing that another beach hut along the ‘iconic’ stretch of seafront has been painted with a French flag for the last two years
With huts selling for up to £35,000, the decision could mean that owners have to pay the council a massive £3,500.
‘This is outrageous. It is nothing other than a stealth tax,’ said Paula Ford, who has owned a beach hut for 30 years, ‘It’s a shocking move by the council and they should be ashamed of themselves.
‘The huts don’t belong to the council. They are privately owned by us, but we just site them on land owned by the council.’
There are 459 beach huts on Hove seafront that are privately owned by residents in the seaside resort, with the annual cost of licences generating around £192,000 for the council.
According to the council, the value of these huts has risen to a range of between £25,000 and £35,000, depending on their location and condition.
David and Susie Howells, who have owned their beach hut for 20 years, said: ‘The beach huts on the promenade are a much-photographed attraction and beach hut owners all play our part as a community that adds value to the seafront experience for both residents and visitors to Brighton and Hove.’
Serena Mitchell, who bought her hut in 2017, also described the proposals as a ‘stealth tax’.
She said: ‘They use the word ‘fee’ as councils are not legally allowed to charge a tax on property sales. The Government can and do.’
There are a total of 459 beach huts along Brighton and Hove’s seafront which are owned privately by locals. According to the council, the value of these huts has risen to a range of between £25,000 and £35,000, depending on their location and condition
In October 2023, Brighton and Hove Council announced controversial plans for a 10 per cent effective sales tax for beach hut owners. Paula Ford (pictured right with friend Chris Halpin), has owned a beach hut along the seafront for 30 years
Ms Ford (pictured) said: ‘This is outrageous. It is nothing other than a stealth tax. ‘The huts don’t belong to the council. They are privately owned by us, but we just site them on land owned by the council’
Councillor Alan Robins, chair of the council’s culture, heritage, sport, tourism and economic development committee, said: ‘Currently the council is not benefitting in any way from the profit made on the sale of a beach hut when most of the value is due to its prime position on the seafront.
‘If the transfer fee is introduced, then the additional revenue can be reinvested back into seafront services such as our lifeguards.
‘It’s an extremely challenging time for local government finances, and the potential income will go towards providing essential life-saving services while offering council land for hut owners to enjoy the seafront.’
MailOnline approached Brighton and Hove City Council for comment.
