Sarah Jessica Parker finally confirms she dated an A-list actor who’s linked to Lisa Marie Presley

Sarah Jessica Parker confirmed she dated an A-list movie star before marrying her husband Matthew Broderick.

The 60-year-old And Just Like That star – who has James, 22, and 16-year-old twins Tabitha and Marion with Matthew – revealed the surprising news while on Watch What Happens Live.

Sarah revealed the pair had a brief romance during filming before she met her spouse in 1991.

Sarah co-starred alongside the 61-year-old actor in the 1992 rom-com Honeymoon in Vegas. 

So who is this mystery A-lister Sarah dated before marrying Matthew? 

Sarah Jessica Parker confirmed she dated an A-list movie star before marrying her husband Matthew Broderick

Her former romantic love interest was Nicholas Cage, her Honeymoon in Vegas co-star. 

Cohen reacted: ‘Oh wow. We’ve got some talking to do!’

Appearing on Watch What Happens Live, host and close friend Andy Cohen had asked her on Sunday’s episode if the gossip was true about them dating, to which she replied: ‘Um, yes I did [date him].’

Nicholas was married to Patricia Arquette from April 1995 until separating nine months later, with divorce finalized in 2001.

Nicholas was married to Lisa Marie Presley from 2002 until 2004, Alice Kim from 2004 until 2016 and Erika Koike in 2019 – however that was annulled four days later.

He is married now to Riko Shibata, and they share a daughter August, two.

He has two sons – Weston, 34, with ex-girlfriend Christina Fulton – and Kal-El, 19,  with Alice. 

Her former romantic love interest was Nicholas Cage , her Honeymoon in Vegas co-star, seen in 1992

Appearing on Watch What Happens Live, host and close friend Andy Cohen had asked her on Sunday’s episode if the gossip was true about them dating, to which she replied: ‘Um, yes I did [date him]’

Sarah and Matthew married on May 19, 1997; the share three children together: son James Wilkie, 22, and twin daughters Tabitha Hodge and Marion Loretta, 16; Sarah and Matthew seen with their twin daughters Tabitha and Marion on April 10, 2025 in NYC 

During her appearance on WWHL, the Sex and the City actress also revealed she was the first to say ‘I love you’ to 63-year-old Lion King star Matthew.

Sarah also dated Robert Downey Jr after they met on Firstborn; The former couple split in 1991 after dating for seven years.

She also dated Michael J. Fox and John F. Kennedy Jr. 

Sarah and Matthew married on May 19, 1997; the share three children together: son James Wilkie, 22, and twin daughters Tabitha Hodge and Marion Loretta, 16.