An outraged mother has revealed how her two profoundly deaf children have been refused access to vital help because they are privately educated.
She was astonished to be told by her local council who fund specialist help for deaf children that private schoolchildren had ‘opted out’ of it because of their choice of school.
The Labour-run council even went on to admit it would also refuse services to blind children if they went to private schools.
The mum from Edinburgh was later told her daughters could only receive help if she paid £120 an hour for it or if their school funded it.
She said both children needed extra support from a teacher of the deaf because otherwise ‘general development and academic progress really suffers’.
This was provided free to her first daughter, now 8, when she was at her current private school’s nursery but, two years later, when her second daughter started the same nursery, the support was denied.
At the same time Edinburgh City Council, who the family pay council tax to, also refused to continue the service on their eldest daughter as she moved into primary.
Complaining to the council last summer and asking them why their policy had clearly changed, the mother was told by the council Head of Education (Inclusion) Lynne Binnie, in an email seen by The Mail on Sunday, that the council’s service was now only provided to children in state schools.
An outraged mother has revealed how her two profoundly deaf children have been refused access to vital help because they are privately educated (File Image)
She was astonished to be told by her local council who fund specialist help for deaf children that private schoolchildren had ‘opted out’ of it because of their choice of school (File Image)
The mum from Edinburgh was later told her daughters could only receive help if she paid £120 an hour for it or if their school funded it (File Image)
Ms Binnie said: ‘Essentially, when a parent makes a decision to educate their child in an independent school, they opt out of central education resources such as the Deaf Support Team.’
She also admitted the council would not provide services for blind and visually impaired children or children who needed educational psychology services if they went to private schools.
The mum told the Mail on Sunday: ‘Obviously, a child has a right to receive appropriate interventions irrespective of which school they are at! To be told this is not the case is shocking.
‘It felt very discriminatory to direct resources to a specific subset of the overall population of children while withdrawing it entirely for the other group.’
The mum says she was later tipped off that even the option to pay for the service had only been opened up because of ‘parental pressure’.
The mum said both children needed extra support from a teacher of the deaf because otherwise ‘general development and academic progress really suffers’ (File Image)
Help was provided free to her first daughter, now 8, when she was at her current private school’s nursery but, two years later, when her second daughter started the same nursery, the support was denied (File Image)
Edinburgh City Council, who the family pay council tax to, also refused to continue the service on their eldest daughter as she moved into primary (File Image)
‘I was told it would cost £120 an hour which is outrageous.’
The mum said she expected her children to have ongoing support with school as well as technical support with their cochlear implants, all of which she had been told by the NHS would be provided by the council’s deaf service.
She added: ‘It makes me so angry that that is the situation. I hate the divisive behaviour that is going on where councils can withdraw services that children need. It is just not fair.’
Criticising the council’s policy as discriminatory, Lorraine Davidson from the Scottish Council of Independent Schools said: ‘Support for deaf children should be a universal service and there should be no discrimination based on a child’s school.’
Craig Hoy MSP called for ‘this shocking discrimination to be urgently addressed by the Scottish Government’, adding: ‘If councils will not provide these essential lifeline services to all children who need them then ministers must step in to ensure every child, regardless of where they are educated, gets the support they need.’
Craig Hoy MSP (above) called for ‘this shocking discrimination to be urgently addressed by the Scottish Government’
But Councillor James Dalgleish, Education, Children and Families Convener said: ‘Independent schools have a responsibility to comply with the Equality Act 2010 and the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004 which includes provision of specialist support to children and young people enrolled at their school who require it.’
The Mail on Sunday’s previous revelations that the same council refused free hospital tuition to sick children on cancer wards if they went to private schools sparked political outrage and ongoing calls to scrap the policy.
And last week, the Principal of George Watson’s College in Edinburgh, one of the UK’s largest private schools, said the city council saved millions a year because so many school children were educated privately.
Lisa Kerr, formerly Head of Gordonstoun, famously attended by King Charles, said: ‘By educating nearly 2500 pupils in 2024, our school saved the public purse a staggering £18.9m with £15.7m of this directly relating to savings made by City of Edinburgh Council from us educating pupils in this area.’
